
See more on Instagram
Scroll through enough posts by food influencers and you begin to wonder whether anyone has had a disappointing dinner since 2019.
The food is incredible. The team is passionate. The room is stunning. You absolutely must go. Someone closes their eyes after the first bite, which apparently means the cooking is exceptional.
We sometimes close ours while trying to swallow.
Then comes the occasional explanation. People have been asking why the account never says anything negative. The answer is delivered as a reassurance: we only share places we love.
Well, that explains the feed. We are less sure it answers the question.
Perhaps we are looking at a business model with a nice haircut.
Some food influencers do publish criticism. We wish more would. Our concern is with those who think keeping quiet is doing everyone a favour.
Under one such post, someone asked why anyone would criticise restaurant owners who work so hard. Better to share the places you enjoy. The account agreed. And there it was. The chef works hard, so we should keep quiet about the dinner.
We have no doubt that running a restaurant is exhausting. Long hours, thin margins, rising costs, staff calling in sick just before service. We would last about forty minutes. Less if someone asked us to make an oat milk cappuccino.
But the person booking a table may also have worked quite hard. They may have saved for the evening, arranged a babysitter and spent weeks looking forward to it. Their money deserves a little consideration too.
Somewhere between the passionate team and the beautiful room, the paying guest seems to have become rather inconvenient.
We follow restaurant accounts because we want help choosing where to eat. There are only so many dinners, and we would prefer fewer disappointing ones. A warning about a dry piece of fish can be every bit as useful as a photograph of a good one.
Possibly more useful. The dry one rarely makes the reel.
Of course, nobody has to publish every bad meal. We certainly do not write about everything we eat. But when we do, you get the evening. We wrote that the Odette Odyssey at Jordnær, a restaurant we adore, did not excite us. We wrote about Koyn in London, and it was not kind. Both belonged on Iternitty.
You do not have to withdraw your affection because the duck arrived cold. You can simply tell us about the duck.
A carefully chosen collection of recommendations can be worth following. Find someone whose taste you understand, try a few places and see whether you agree.
Choosing which restaurants to recommend is one thing. Choosing which parts of the dinner to mention is another.
A recommendation should still tell us what the evening was like.
We loved the cooking, but the tables were so close together that we now know why the couple next to us are getting divorced. The starter was excellent. The main course was not. We would return, although we would order differently.
That is useful. We can make a decision with that.
A restaurant can be worth visiting and still have things worth mentioning. You do not have to withdraw your affection because the duck arrived cold. You can simply tell us about the duck.
There is also the argument that taste is subjective. Everyone likes different things.
Yes. We had assumed that was why we were reading somebody’s opinion.
We do not need a stranger to possess the correct palate. We need to understand theirs.
Paying our own bill does not make us immune to any of this. We can be seduced by a famous name, a lovely room or someone remembering us from a previous visit. We can spend a ridiculous amount on dinner and sit there trying to persuade ourselves it was worth it.
We have had plenty of practice.
Admitting that the main course was disappointing might spoil the Instagram post. It might also save someone an expensive evening.
We want restaurants to do well. We want to find places we love and go back to them. There is very little pleasure in paying for a disappointing dinner, and writing about it does not refund the bill.
But we would rather have known before booking.
The restaurant has our money. It can survive our opinion.
We use cookies to improve your experience. You can accept or deny their use. Not consenting may affect site features.